An intergenerational tale that unlocks a purposefully held family secret is a common one. It is the mystery and the slow unraveling of the past that should keep the audience/reader engaged.
In the Shadow of the Greenbrier, by Emily Matchar, was published in March. It follows four generations of a Jewish family living in West Virginia and their interaction with the local hotel, Greenbrier Resort. Specifically, the audience follows the mother/daughter duo of Sylvia and Doree.
1942, the hotel is turned into a high-end prison for enemy combatants. For the sake of her family and their locally run store, she has put up a front. But the reality is that Sylvia is not a happy camper when it comes to her marriage. Her world turns upside down when she meets one of the prisoners.
In 1959, Doree is a high school senior and eager to leave her small town for college. A handsome newcomer catches her eye. While her young heart is being turned, her brother Alan is constantly getting into trouble. When the shit hits the fan, Doree will have to choose between potential romance and her family.
I wanted to like this book. Matchar’s narrative is well-researched and well-written. The problem is that I was underwhelmed. The big reveal is not as earth-shattering as I thought it would be.
Do I recommend it? No.
In the Shadow of the Greenbrier is available wherever books are sold.